NNSquad - Network Neutrality Squad
[ NNSquad ] Canada goes crazy
(Thanks to Aleks for this pointer)
http://www.cbc.ca/technology/story/2010/05/06/crtc-usage-based-billing-internet.html?ref=rss
The idea of charging people for bits consumed is a crazy idea since you
aren't consuming bits. We've been through this before - do I need to explain
once again how bad the idea is?
. It creates scarcity. A copper wire (or fiber or radio) is just
sitting there idle. We limit how much can be used.
. Even if there is a temporary constriction somewhere else it means
we can't use the capacity locally. To take it to an extreme imagine if there
is such a limit in your house - you can't copy too many files between your
computers.
. FiOS VoD, for example, goes over IP through my router. I can't
watch much "TV" [sic] if the limit is applied to those bits. If the limit is
not applied we have a vertical playing field where the provider has all the
advantages.
. Any sane price doesn't allow making video affordable if we're
going to make the cost of other uses visible.
. As with SMS any market that permits prices to be millions of time
cost (determined by competition with Moore's law) isn't really a market in a
useful sense. It's rent taking gone to hostage taking.
But basically it shows a deep inability to comprehend the very concept of
connectivity using best efforts. It's railroaders banning the use of roads
unless you buy a ticket for a ride every time you leave your driveway even
if it is just to reorder the cars in the driveway.
Others care to add to the reasons why this is crazy?
http://frankston.com/public
[ And coming soon to a U.S. ISP near you (and me) too, I'll wager.
Since the FCC chairman has shown no interest in including any
sort of pricing or realistically effective competition-enhancing
elements in his proposed "third-way" regulatory plan, the
dominant ISPs are ensured a captive audience of users who will
"pay through their noses until their skulls are a vacuum" (as one
high level ISP executive expressed it to me yesterday --
picturesque, this guy, and a master of invective as well ...)
-- Lauren Weinstein
NNSquad Moderator ]